An American Family History

The Watauga Settlement

Click on image to enlarge.

Carter County is in northeastern Tennessee. It was part of the Washington District of North Carolina organized in 1775. In 1777, the district became Washington County, North Carolina.
Daniel Boone (1734-1820) was a frontiersman who became an American folk hero. The Boone family were members of the Gwynedd Monthly Meeting. He is best know from his exploration of Virginia and Kentucky.
The Seneca Trail or The Great Indian Warpath was a Native American trail from Pennsylvania through the Shenandoah Valley. It was the route used by early settlers migrating to eastern Tennessee. In the 1760's it was widened to allow the army to defend the fort on the Holston and this encouraged increased migration to East Tennessee.

The American folk hero, David "Davy" Crockett (1786 – 1836), grew up in East Tennessee.

The Watauga settlement was was south of the Holston River, on the Watauga and Nolichucky Rivers in the colony of North Carolina. There were three main settlements in the area known as Watauga, Carter's Valley, and Nolichucky. Most settlers came down the Great Valley through Virginia, while others went through gaps in the Unaka Range from North Carolina. The settlers believed they had settled in Virginia. However, all except the North Holston community were in North Carolina on land that belonged to the Cherokee Nation. They were told to relocate, but instead negotiated with the Cherokee to lease the land.

Julius Dugger and Andrew Greer were the first white men to settle in the Watauga Country. They settled about three miles above the present town of Elizabethton.

The first permanent settlement in Tennessee was made in 1769 on Boones Creek by Captain William Bean, and his wife Lydia. Their son, Russell Bean, is said to have been the first European child born in Tennessee.

According to Masengill, Henry Massengill, Sr. settled in 1769 as one of the first settlers.

In the fall of the year 1771, Anthony Bledsoe ran the boundary line between the Colonies of Virginia and North Carolina, far enough west to ascertain that the Watauga settlement was in North Carolina, and Alexander Cameron, the British agent, immediately ordered the settlers on the Watauga to move oflf of the Indian lands. James Robertson and John Sevier, two of the leading members of the Watauga settlement, immediately set about to devise ways and means by which they could avoid the order of the British agent. They could not buy the lands from the Indians, because the purchase was prohibited, but there was no law prohibiting a lease of the land, and in the year 1774, the Indians leased to the settlers on the Watauga the lands in the Watauga Valley and all was peace once again. (History of Southwest Virginia)

In 1771, Colonel James Robertson brought 16 Regulator families across the mountains from North Carolina. The group included his brothers and brother-in-law. Valentine Sevier, Sr. came from the Shenandoah Valley. John Sevier settled on the Nolachucky. His sons, John and James Sevier, located on farms nearby.

Jonathan Tipton and Joseph Tipton (brothers of Colonel John Tipton) had moved to the area accompanied by their father, Jonathan, who was over seventy-five years of age. 

Colonel John C. Carter (1737) and his son Colonel Landon C. Carter (1760) settled on the western side of the Holston River about 1770. Both John and Landon were Colonels in the American Revolution. Carter County, Tennessee was named for Landon.

Many settlers came to the Holston and Watauga Settlements after the Battle of Alamance in May, 1771, when there was a mass migration of settlers from central North Carolina to the frontier regions.

These early settlers formed the Watauga Association which was was semi-autonomous government created in 1772. The first five men appointed to administer the Watauga settlement were John Sevier, James Robertson, Charles Robertson, Zachariah Isbell, and John Carter.

Sinking Creek Baptist Church was organized 1772 in Washington County (now Carter County). 

In 1772 Jacob Brown located on the north bank of the Nolachucky River. He had brought a packhorse loaded with goods with which he purchased the lease of land from the indigenous people (and later received a deed) for a large tract on both sides of the Nolachucky. He sold this land to settlers. The government of North Carolina, however, refused to recognize the deeds' validity and continued to make grants in the territory.

The John Carr family came from South Carolina, and was one of the first in Washington County, Tennessee.

Fort Watauga (or Caswell) was built at the Sycamore Shoals of the Watauga River in 1775–1776 by the Watauga Association, to defend settlers from Indian (primarily Cherokee) attacks, which were in part instigated by the British. It was a group of cabins arranged in a rectangle connected by stockade walls of sharp pointed poles.

On March 25, 1775 the Watauga Purchase of the East Tennessee lands from the Cherokees was made.

The first settlers on Little Limestone were Robert and James Allison. In 1775 Michael Bawn and James Pearn were each granted permission by the county to build a grist-mill on Little Limestone.

[The Watauga Fort was attacked], July twenty-first 1776. At day-break, when there were a large number of people gathered there, and the women were out-side milking the cows, a large body of Cherokees fired on the milkers; but they all fortunately escaped to the fort, the gates of which were thrown open for their reception.

After the battle with the indigenous people at Fort Watauga in 1776, a second fort was built upriver on lands owned by Valentine Sevier, Sr., but later owned by Solomon and Abraham Hart, sons of Leonard Hart.

Legislative Journal of the Provincial Congress at Halifax, North Carolina Monday, December 23rd, 1776

Resolved that John Carter be Colonel, John Sevier, Lieutenant Colonel, Charles Roberson 1st Major, and Jacob Womack, 2nd Major, for the District of Washington, and that commissions issued accordingly.

Resolved, That Col. John Carter be supplied with 200 wt. of gun powder from the magazine in Halifax, for the defense of the District of Washington, and Mr. Christopher Dudley is hereby directed to furnish him with the same.

The Johnson City area settled in 1777 by settlers who received grants from North Carolina. Among those settlers were the Young, Jones, Tipton, Jobe, Denton, and O'Neill families. The community was first known as Blue Plum. The grants were awarded in response to Great Britain's arming of Indian tribes to fight American revolutionaries. Each head of household received 640 acres and 100 acres for his wife and 100 for each child.

In November, 1778

Ord[ered]. Jacob Womack, Jesse Walton, Geo. Russell, Jospeh Willson, Zach. Isbell, and Benjamin Gist appointed to lay off the place for erecting the Court house, prison stocks, and the said return is ord. filed in the court office.

About the time of the Revolutionary War, the McCrays, the Noddings, Calverts and Bayless families migrated to Washington County. Daniel McCray and William Nodding, and both are on the 1786 list of voters and received land grants in Washington County.

Jeremiah Dungan, acquired land in the area in 1778 and built a mill on Brush Creek in the present town of Watauga.

"The Battle of the State of Franklin" took place at John Tipton's house in 1788. North Carolina authorities seized some of the people who John Sevier had enslaved. Sevier and his supporters came to the Tipton house to reclaim them. The North Carolinians rebuffed them and this signaled the end of the State of Franklin.

Two sons of Noah Range were early settlers. Peter and Elizabeth Range settled on Knob Creek in Washington County, Tennessee, in 1779. Jacob Range improved land in 1779 on the Big Harpeth River and later petitioned for a grand to that land.

In 1779, Tidence Lane established the Buffalo Ridge Baptist Church.

The Jobe family was also among the early settlers.

On September 25, 1780, the Overmountain Men assembled on the Sycamore Shoals of the Watauga to begin their march to the Battle of Kings Mountain. There were approximately 1,100 men.

John Hendrix and Hannah Kelly moved to the Watauga settlement about 1780

In 1780 John Carter and his son, Landon C. Carter, built a two story frame home with two fireplaces.

Samuel Weaver purchased 600 acres on Little Limestone creek (#629) about 1784.

About 1782 members of the Broyles family moved to east Tennessee. They lived on Little Limestone Creek.

Jacob Brown gave the land for the Cherokee Creek Baptist Church which was chartered in September, 1783.

In late 1783, North Carolina passed an act to sell vacant land to settlers. This law, known as the Land-Grab Act, was in effect from October 20, 1783 to May 25, 1784. The entire western reserve was open to purchase by anyone who could pay 10 pounds per 100 acres.

Colonel John Tipton moved to the Watagua settlement in 1783.

David Matlock received a warrant for a 540-acre tract of land in Washington County in 1782 on the west side of the Doe River including the big spring and the bottom on both sides of Doe River.

Landon Carter entered

1500 acres of land as a Boundry for Iron Works in the fork of Wataugah and Doe River Joining the Land of said Carter also Isaac Lincoln, Godfry Carriger, Teter Nave, Leonard Bowers, William Duggard, Elisha Humphreys, David Matlock, Deceased and Emanuel Carter, Deceased.

Also 1500 acres on the South of Doe River Joining the lands of Sam'l Tipton, Michael Tullis, David Matlock, Thomas Millsaps, William Sharp, Rich'd Kite, Isaac Eden, Sen., Wm. Bundy, Josiah Clarke, Ralph Humphreys & Joshua Houghton, Sen.

In 1784, Zachariah Isbell, John Sevier and Jesse Walton were appointed to confiscate the properties of Tories in Washington County.

In 1784, William Ellis purchased 325 on Boone's Creek.

In August, 1784 delegates from Washington and two other western North Carolina counties (all now in Tennessee), declared their Independence from North Carolina because of perceived neglect, and misuse by North Carolina’s legislature. By May, 1785 they had petitioned to be admitted to the United States as the State of Franklin. The request was denied.

John Nicholas (1753) and Margaretha Mottern were from Berks County Pennsylvania. He served in Shraedel's Company during the Revolution. On June 10, 1788 they bought 160 acres from Juliana and David Shults in Sullivan County.

The John Miller-Adam Sell house was built in 1788 on Knob Creek.

Mordecai Price received a patent for four hundred acres on Sinking Creek at the waters of Wattauga river on May 18, 1789.

In 1790 Reverend Samuel Doak and Hezikiah Balch organized the Hebron Church in the Knob Creek settlement.

Reverend Samuel Doak

In 1791, the Treaty of Holston proclaimed a treaty with the Cherokee in Eastern Tennessee.

On July 13, 1792 Moses Humphreys purchased a tract of land on the north side of Boones Creek in Washington County from William Ellis for 50 "current money."

Bowlin and Mary (Lee) Curtis settled by the Watagua River about 1792.


Washington County, Tennessee,was established in 1777 as Washington County, North Carolina. From 1784 to 1788,it was part of the State of Franklin.

The Battle of Kings Mountain was a decisive battle of the American Revoluton. It took place on October 7, 1780, nine miles south of the present-day town of Kings Mountain, North Carolina. The Patriot militia defeated the Loyalist militia commanded by British Major Patrick Ferguson.

The State of Franklin was an unrecognized, independent state in what is now eastern Tennessee. It was created in 1784 with the intent of becoming the fourteenth state. Its first capital was Jonesborough. It existed for about four and a half years and then North Carolina re-assumed control.

Slavery is an immoral system of forced labor where people are treated as property to be bought and sold. It was legal in the American Colonies and the United States until the Civil War.

A land patent is an exclusive land grant made by the government. The certificate that grants the land rights is also called first-title deed and final certificate. In the United States, all land can be traced back to the original land patent.

The Holston River in northeast Tennessee has given its name to Holston Mountain and the Holston Valley.

Teter Nave


Tennessee was admitted to the Union on June 1, 1796. It was initially part of North Carolina.

Carter County, Tennessee was organized from Washington County on April 9, 1796. Elizabethton is the county seat.

1794 Washington County Poll Tax-(Capt. Carriger's Company)
for the part that would become Carter County, Tennessee in June 1796.

A poll is a person and was probably a male adult laborer. The head of household would pay taxes for himself and any adult sons or white servants he had, as well as for the people he had enslaved.

Teter Nave 350 acres 1 white poll
John Gillam 1 white poll
William Harden 1 white poll
Isaac Kite 1 white poll
Richard Kite 150 acres, 1 white poll
Humphrey Garland, 1 white poll
James Price 210 acres, 1 white poll
Abraham Nave, 1 white poll
Gideon Matlock 544 acres, 1 white poll
William Matlock, 1 white poll
Pharaoh Cobb 1000 acres, 1 white poll, 7 black polls
Christian Shoultz, 1 white poll
Christian Shoultz, Jr., 1 white poll
Christian Peters, 1 white poll
Jacob Heatherrick, Jr. , 1 white poll
John Roberson 50 acres, 1 white poll
Richard Cox, 1 white poll
Leonard Bowers 50 acres, 1 white poll
Christian Stover, 1 white poll
Jno Parker Moore 1 0
Abraham Sevier 142 acres, 1 white poll
Elisha Humphreys 360 acres, 1 white poll
Valentine Sevier, Sr. 410 acres, no polls
Abraham Helton, 1 white poll
John Keer 1 0 , 1 white poll
Stephen Redman, 1 white poll
John Hilton, 1 white poll
John Musgroves, 1 white poll
Godfrey Carriger 2324 acres, 1 white poll, 2 black Polls
Isaac Lincoln 670, 1 white poll
Samuel Tipton 890 acres, 1 white poll
Thomas Tipton 386 acres, 1 white poll
James Lacey, 1 white poll
Philemon Lacey, 1 white poll
John Humphreys, 1 white poll
George Emmert (b. 1757) 297 acres, 1 white poll
James Cooper, 1 white poll
Thomas Millard, 1 white poll
Thomas Duncan, 1 white poll
William Flanary 100 acres, 1 white poll
Michael Carriger 156 acres, 1 white poll
Godfrey Carriger Jr. 222 acres, 1 white poll
James Right, 1 white poll
Joseph Large, 1 white poll
Robert Large, 1 white poll
Hugh Forbush, 1 white poll
Nicholas Carriger 450 acres, 1 white poll
James Patrick, 1 white poll
John Michael
Smith Peters 745 acres 1 white poll
Robert Musgrove 640, 1 white poll
Thomas Greer, 1 white poll
John Nowlan, 1 white poll
William Henry, 1 white poll
John Arrendell 200 acres, 1 white poll
James Ivey 50 acres, 1 white poll
John Garland 200 acres, 1 white poll
Landon Carter 2240 acres, 1 white poll, 6 black polls
Abraham Wilton
Jeremiah Bass 280 acres, 1 white poll, 8 black polls
Abraham Drake 400 acres, 1 white poll
John Worley, 1 white poll, 5 black polls
Alexander Greer, 1 white poll, 5 black polls
Robert Johnston, 1 white poll
Peter Helton, 1 white poll
Thomas Little, 1 white poll
John Carter, 1 white poll. 2 black polls
Andrew Greer 1700 acres, no white polls, 3 black polls

East Tennessee is part of Appalachia. At the end of the French and Indian War, colonists began drifting into the area. In 1769, they first settled along the Watauga River. During the Revolution, the Overmountain Men defeated British loyalists at the Battle of Kings Mountain. The State of Franklin was formed in the 1780s, but never admitted to the Union.

February 1, 1796 Leonard Hart obtained 239 acres next to the Hendrix Family in the Turkeytown.

In 1799 the Knob Creek Brethren Chruch was established.

In 1799 there was a petition in Washington County asking for marriages performed under the State of Franklin to be recognized.





March 22, 1814-(Court Minutes book B-240) Security agreement. The Tennessee General Assembly has passed a state lottery and the proceeds were divided among counties. Carter County received $16,000 and the Commissioners decided to purchase salt with the money, re-sell at cost to the citizens.

Abraham Hendry was Chairman of the Court, he and all other members were bound to the agreement. Others include,
Robert Blackmore, John Miller,William B. Carter, Christian Carriger, Moses Humphrey, James Kelly, Jahu Humphrey, Daniel Moore, Leonard Bowers, John Lyons, Richard Webster, David McNabb, Leonard Hart.


Boones Creek Christian Church started because of a controversy over the baptism of Fanny Renfro. In 1824 Jerial Dodge baptized her at the Sinking Creek Baptist Church, and the Baptist Association decided against the baptism.

James Miller and others left the church. The revival that followed on Boones Creek was called the “Great Meeting.” The revival also attracted members of the Buffalo Ridge Baptist Church.


Teter Nave

1830 census Carter County near Leonard Hart

Alexander Lacey
James Williams
Glubman Justice
Anguish McIntosh
Sarah Justice
Jacob Miller
Alexander Morton
George Pearce
Zachariah Campbell
Elisha Campbell
Daniel Campbell
Isaac Campbell
George Smith
Daniel Smith
Ezekiel Smith
Zacheriah Cole
Silas Hilton
Bayless Miller
Valentine Bowers
Alfred W. Taylor
Samuel A. Ervin
Abraham Nave, Jr.
William Lion
Pleasant Williams
Abraham Row
Anderson Hite
Leonard Hart, Sr.
Leonard Hart, Jr.
John Clivis
Benjamin Hyder, Jr.
John Fletcher
James L. Bradley
David C. Moody
George W. Grunuay
George Lacey
James I. Tipton
Henry H. Ware
Moses Blevins
Abner McLeod
John Scott
John Rollins
Samuel Drake
Godfrey Nave
Archibald Williams
Isaac Tipton, Jr.
John C. Helms
Toueman Hilton
John Hawhaway
William Estep
James Edens
Nathaniel Edens
Mark Lacey


1840 census Carter County near Leonard Hart

Aggregate Grut
Jeriah Woods
John Morris
Elizabeth Blevins
William Carter
Jonathan Poland
Jonathan Crouch
Peter W. Emmert (1771, son of George Emmert)
Elizabeth Emmert
William Bishop
Drice Penick
Elizabeth William
John C. Lang
Mark Lang
Eli Campbell
William Turner
James Turner
William C. Renfro
Leonard Hart (1758)
Solomon Hart (son of Leonard Hart)
Abraham Hart (1811, son of Leonard Hart)
Lewis Emmert
Richard Kelley
Armstead B. Cooper
Loyd Arrowsod
John Berry
Abraham McMillin
Delina [Dulcina Hendrix, married Isaac Crouch] Crouch
Tobias Hendrix


Alison BarronBean BlevinsBoringBroylesCarrCobbColbaugh Cole CoxCross CrouchCurtisDeckDenton Dungan EmmertGreenwayHartHendrixHendryHicks Hunt Humphreys Isbell JacksonJobe King LattureLittle Looney MaloneMassengilMauckMcCorkleMcKinleyMillerMooreNavePitts RangeReneauRhea SevierSmithSmithStanfieldTipton TullisWaggoner Webb





Bauman & Dreisbach

©Roberta Tuller 2017